The New Prophecy
| Midnight |  |
| Moonrise | |
| Dawn |  |
| Starlight |  |
| Twilight | |
| Sunset | |
| Average Rating: | |
The New Prophecy is a mixed bag. On one hand, it really shakes the series up introducing new conflicts, points of view, and situations. On the other hand, it can be very disjointed, and even boring at times.
I love the concept of this series - taking cats from every clan, forcing them to journey together, and find a new home for the clans. It could lead to some compelling relationships, tensions, and drama. However, it just feels a little undercooked. The Chosen Cats should be forming lasting friendships, but in execution do not have a lot of chemistry. Some of them have little to no interaction (Tawnypelt especially). It would’ve been nice to have every Chosen Cat get to be a Point of View character, especially Crowfeather who falls in forbidden love with not one, but two cats. (Even with his lousy personality).
Despite my gripes, I have a weird relationship with the series. The characters, on paper, are my favorites in Warriors. I love Brambleclaw, Squirrelflight, Mothwing, Hawkfrost, Feathertail, Leafpool, Stormfur, Crowfeather, and even Tawnypelt. I can see so much potential in this arc, and where certain areas could have been refined. Of all the arcs, it's probably the one I think about the most just for imagining different dialogue moments or relationships. That's why I'm so thankful for fandom and fandom rewrites showing off the true potential of The New Prophecy.
The New Prophecy - Manga and Short Stories
| Skyclan and the Stranger | |
| Graystripe's Adventure | |
| Leafpool's Wish | |
| Wind's of Change | |
Skyclan and the Stranger - So happy to see another story about Skyclan! Especially one that gives some background into the mysterious Sol, who turns out to just be a really lousy cat. Leafstar shines as a capable and confident leader of Skyclan, dealing with whatever comes her way.
Graystripe's Adventure - The first Warriors "manga"! This is a travel story about how Graystripe meets Millie and finds his way home. I’m not a huge fan of travel stories and I wasn’t super into Graystripe and Mille’s chemistry. It was fine for filling in some story gaps, but nothing incredible.
Leafpool’s Wish - A nice tale showing the conflict Leafpool faces when she realizes she’s pregnant with Crowfeather’s kits. I liked seeing her bond with Squirrelflight, and how they were able to keep the parenting situation of Lionkit, Jaykit, and Hollykit a secret. I HATE how Yellowfang, and by extension Star Clan, lie about Squirrelflight's fertility. It's disgusting.
Winds of Change - A great graphic novel that gives the reader Mudclaw's perspective of the whole, "Tallstar makes Onewhisker deputy behind Mudclaw's back" situation. Mudclaw's motiviations are completely understandable, even if his actions are wrong.